What Men Live By, by Leo Tolstoy, L&D Allen Press, 1951

Each time I am able to get my hands on an L&D Allen Press book, I become more and more impressed with their accomplishments. For nearly forty years, they published beautiful fine press books, all letterpress with hand made paper and hand bound.  Besides some stunning folio size works, their smaller size works leave little to be desired. For example, their edition of Leo Tolstoy’s What Men Live By is nearly perfect in execution.

Printed damp on hand-made Maidstone paper, the handset Romanee typeset and hand colored wood block illustrations by Mallette Dean provide perfect examples of how the old, traditional way of creating books far exceeds what modern technology accomplishes today.  Incredibly easy on the eyes, the physical parts of the book simply fade into the background, allowing the text, the illustrations and your imagination to take the forefront. In short, this is how it should be.

What Men Live By is a short story published by Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910) in 1855.  Simon is a poor Russian shoemaker, married to Matrena. “Work was cheap but bread was dear, and what he earned he spent for food.” Simon heads into town to try to collect over five rubles owed to him by various people so that he can buy sheepskin to have a winter coat that he can share with his wife. Nobody is able to pay him so he dejectedly starts to walk back home when, as he approaches a holy shrine, he runs across a naked man, poor of health. Simon initially tries to avoid him but his conscience gets the best of him and he helps him, ultimately taking him home. Simon’s wife is initially angry at him, but eventually warms to the stranger also, which causes the stranger to smile briefly. The stranger, named Michael, only tells Simon and Matrena that he is being punished by God.

Michael stays with Simon and Matrena and becomes and assistant to Simon, making shoes. One day, a rich nobleman comes in with special leather and gives strict instructions for a pair of boots, threatening Simon with arrest if he makes any mistakes. Michael, seemingly looking beyond the nobleman, briefly smiles again. Instead of making boots as demanded, Michael make a pair of soft slippers. As Simon notices what Michael has done and begins to get angry, a messenger comes in saying that the nobleman has died and that his widow would like funeral slippers made with the  leather, instead of boots. Simon is astounded.

A poor women comes in one day with two girls, one crippled, and asks for three shoes. Michael stares at the girls as Simon asks the woman about the girls and how the one was made lame. The woman explains they are not her biological children and that the mother of the girls, on her deathbed, accidentally crushed the leg of the crippled girl. The woman mentions she did not have the heart to send them to an orphanage, so instead she took them in as her own. Michael smiles when he hears this.

When the woman leaves, Michael, with a glow around him, tells Simon God has forgiven him and he is now going to leave. Simon realizes Michael is not an ordinary man, and asks Michael about the glow around him and the three times he smiled. Michael says:

Light shines from me because I have been punished, but now God has pardoned me.  And I smiled three times, because God sent me here to learn three truths, and I have learnt them.

Michael explains that he is an Angel, and God was punishing him for disobeying him when God had told him to bring a woman to her next life; she had pleaded with Michael to let her live to raise her children and Michael had let her live. God sent Michael back to earth, to take the woman’s soul and then stripped him of his wings, telling him he must find the answers to the following questions in order to be an angel again: What dwells in man?, What is not given to man?, and What do men live by?

Story spoiler follows, so do not read if you plan on reading the book!

Michael explains that each time he smiled, it was because he learned the answer to one of those questions. He learned ‘what dwells in man‘ early on when Simon and Matrena took him in. What dwells in man is love.  He learned ‘what is not given to man‘ when the rich nobleman ordered shoes for an event in the future, not realizing he would be dead by then. What is not given to man is to know their own needs. He learned ‘what men live by’ through the example set by the woman raising the two children whose mother had died. What men live by is the living God within them. Michael says:

I have learnt that all men are to live not by care of themselves, but by love….all men live not by the thought they spend on their own welfare, but because love exists in man…I understood that God does not wish men to live part, and consequently he does not reveal to them what each one needs for himself; but he wishes them to live united, and therefore reveals to each of them what is necessary for all. I have now understood that though it seems to men that they live by care for themselves, in truth it is love alone by which they live. He who has love, is in God, and God is in him, for God is love.

Michael is raised back to heaven.

Leo Tolstoy is one the greatest novelists in history, with two books, War and Peace and Anna Karenina generally considered two of the greatest novels ever written. Both novels are certainly at the peak of realistic fiction. In the 1870’s he had a spiritual awakening, resulting in him becoming a fervent Christian anarchist. His views on non-violence were to have significant impact on twentieth century leaders such as Mohandas Gandhi and Martin Luther King, Jr.

About the Edition

  • Type face is Romanee (designed by J. van Krimpen, imported from Holland, this its first use in an American-made book), hand set
  • Paper is all-rag and-made Maidstone, from England, printed damp
  • Wood engravings by Mallette Dean, hand-illuminated in three colors by Dorothy Allen
  • Designed, printed on a hand-press, and bound by Lewis and Dorothy Allen at The L-D Allen Press in 1951
  • Binding consists of black “binder’s vellum” for the spine, with red, Italian Fabriano cover paper over boards, stamped with title and wood engraving
  • 9″ x 6″
  • Limited edition of 150


(All pictures on Books and Vines are exclusively provided to highlight and visualize the work being reviewed.  A side benefit, hopefully, is encouraging healthy sales of fine press books for the publishers and fine retailers that specialize in these types of books (of which Books and Vines has no stake or financial interest). Please note that works photographed are copyrighted by the publisher, author and/or illustrator as indicated in the articles. Permission to use contents from these works for anything outside of fair use purposes must come directly from the copyright owner and no permission is granted or implied to use photo’s found on Books and Vines for any purpose that would infringe on the rights of the copyright owner.)

What Men Live By, Allen Press, Slipcase Spine
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Book Spine
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Book Cover
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Title Page
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Opening
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Sample Page with Text and Illustration #1
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Sample Page with Text and Illustration #2
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Sample Page with Text and Illustration #3
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Sample Page with Text and Illustration #4
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Sample Page with Text and Illustration #5
What Men Live By, Allen Press, Colophon

6 thoughts on “What Men Live By, by Leo Tolstoy, L&D Allen Press, 1951

  1. This book was the Allen’s first edition printed on damped handmade paper on a true handpress.

    “For damping the paper we adopted the antiquated method used since the days of Gutenberg: immersing 15 to 20 sheets in a tub of water, then devoting tedious hours to reversing and shuffling the sheets to acquire even damping throughout the stack. During the printing we noticed a slight brownish cast to the black ink. We learned later that it was caused by heavy rust deposits in the pipes of the old water-oriented cottage.” – excerpt from The Allen Press Bibliography

  2. Unfortunately, there are no fine press or private press editions of either Tolstoy’s Confession or Kafka’s Letter to My Father that I am aware of.

  3. Jack, thanks much for turning me on to Allen Press. What a pleasure it has been discovering these. I just love 19th century Russian literature, I really do, with Tolstoy of course very near the top. An interesting man, great story teller, full of passion. Are there any fine press editions of Confession, or for that matter Kafka’s Letter to My Father?

  4. Aren’t these Allen Press books delightful 🙂 ?? !!

    Regarding Lev Tolstoy, although he is known primarily through his long novels ‘War and Peace’ and ‘Anna Karenina’, following his religious awakening and spiritual conversion away from the Russian Orthodox church to a deeply felt secular faith in God without a church acting as an intermediary, he never published a long novel again and his works became progressively shorter in length and devoted primarily to spiritual matters. His conversion is described in an autobiographical work called ‘Confession’ which is (along with Franz Kafka’s “Letter to My Father’) one of the greatest autobiographical works of all time.

    His novellas, short stories, and religious parables are remarkable works in which he is able to penetrate to the heart of the matter and express his profound faith in God in the most spare, direct language. He says more in fifty pages than today’s authors say in 800 to 900 pages. He is one of the great masters of the short story form and is not really recognized as such, similar to James Joyce. If Tolstoy had never written ‘War and Peace’ and ‘Anna Karenina’ his reputation as one of the world’s greatest authors would still be assured merely on the basis of his shorter works.

Leave a Reply